Navigating Difficult Conversations: A Leadership Skill You Can Master

As a leader, you’ll inevitably face difficult conversations. Whether it’s addressing a performance issue, resolving interpersonal conflicts, or confronting a situation that’s been simmering under the surface, these moments are unavoidable.

As uncomfortable as they may be, the ability to navigate difficult conversations with skill is one of the most important aspects of leadership. The key is knowing how to address issues directly, before they fester, escalate, or undermine your working relationships.

“Sometimes the most important conversations are the most difficult to navigate.” –Jeanne Phillips, aka “Dear Abby”

In this blog, we’ll explore strategies that can help you manage these conversations effectively, ensuring that both you and the other party come away feeling heard, respected, and aligned toward a productive resolution. Mastering these techniques will help you maintain healthy relationships at work and elevate your leadership.

As uncomfortable as they may be, the ability to navigate these conversations with skill is one of the most important aspects of leadership.

1. Prepare: Set yourself up for success

A little preparation goes a long way when it comes to difficult conversations. Before you sit down to talk with someone, it’s critical to understand your own goals, motivations, and emotional state.

a. Determine your goal

Start by asking yourself: What is the purpose of this conversation? What outcome do I want? Am I aiming to address a specific behaviour or to clarify an issue that’s impacting my work or team dynamics?

It’s essential to be clear on your intentions. If your goal is simply to vent or express how upset you are, you may not be ready yet for a constructive conversation. If, instead, your goal is to improve the situation, solve a problem, or improve your working relationship, you’ll be in a better mindset to engage with the other person in a productive way.

b. Shift from judgement to curiosity

One of the biggest obstacles to successful difficult conversations is our tendency to judge other people’s actions through the lens of our own emotions. This can escalate the situation, cloud our judgement, and prevent us from really understanding the other person’s perspective. To avoid this, try to approach the conversation with curiosity instead of judgement.

Instead of thinking, Why are they acting this way? What are they doing to me? shift to What else might be going on here? What could be motivating this person’s behaviour? When you look at the situation from a place of curiosity, you remove some of the emotional charge and open the door to constructive dialogue. This shift makes it easier to approach the conversation from a more neutral standpoint, giving you a better chance of uncovering root causes that may not be immediately obvious.

Lead your team with empathy and confidence.

Be trauma-informed.

Show me training options

2. Set the Stage: Ensure a productive conversation

Successful difficult conversations don’t happen in a vacuum – they require the right environment, mindset, and conditions to thrive. Here’s how to ensure you set yourself and the other person up for success.

a. Invite the person to talk

It’s important to create a space where both parties feel comfortable discussing the issue. Don’t ambush the person or spring a tough conversation on them when they’re distracted or stressed. Instead, invite them to have the conversation at a time when you both can give each other your full attention.

You might say something like, “I’ve been thinking about something that I’d like to discuss with you when you have a moment. Can we find a time to talk?” This ensures they’re mentally prepared and open to the discussion.

b. Set ground rules

Establish clear guidelines for the conversation. Be upfront about the topic, why it’s important to you, and what kind of outcome you’re hoping for. This prevents misunderstandings and helps set a collaborative tone.

You might say, “I’d like to talk about the recent project timelines. I’m feeling concerned about how we’re progressing, and I’d love to find a way we can work together to make sure we’re meeting our goals. My hope is that we can figure out a solution together.”

c. Point to a joint interest

Frame the conversation as something that benefits both of you. When people understand that the conversation isn’t just about addressing your own grievances, but about improving the situation for everyone involved, they’re more likely to feel engaged and open. Highlight how resolving the issue will lead to a better outcome for the team, the project, or the work environment as a whole.

You might say, “I really enjoy working with you and want to ensure that we can continue to have a productive and collaborative working relationship.”

Don’t ambush the person or spring a tough conversation on them when they’re distracted or stressed.

3. Let Them Talk: Foster two-way communication

Difficult conversations are a two-way street. As much as you may want to get your point across, it’s equally important to listen and allow the other person to share their perspective.

a. Don’t try to “win”

It’s natural to want to “win” an argument or get your point across, but this approach can quickly turn the conversation into a conflict rather than a constructive exchange. If you want the conversation to go well, your goal should be problem solving, not scoring points. Keep in mind that this isn’t a competition – you’re both working toward a resolution, not a victory.

b. Check your assumptions

We all make assumptions about why people do the things they do, but often our guesses are inaccurate. Instead of jumping to conclusions, be open to hearing their side of the story. You might learn that there are factors at play you hadn’t considered, which can help you find a better solution.

Instead of saying, “You’re always late with your reports,” you might say, “I’ve noticed a pattern of late reports, and I’d like to understand if there’s something going on that’s making it difficult to meet the deadlines.” This opens the door for a more honest and productive conversation.

c. Use “I” statements

Focus on expressing your own feelings and perspective without attacking or blaming the other person. “I” statements help you take ownership of your emotions and avoid sounding accusatory.

For example, instead of saying, “You never listen to me,” say, “I feel unheard when I don’t get feedback after I share my ideas.” This approach centres the conversation on your feelings and needs rather than on the other person’s behaviour, which helps reduce defensiveness and encourages empathy.

4. End with Resolution: Move towards action

A difficult conversation isn’t truly over until you’ve made progress toward a resolution. This is where many conversations break down – if you don’t establish clear next steps, the issue may remain unresolved, and old tensions may resurface.

a. Thank the other person

Regardless of the outcome, take a moment to thank the other person for engaging in the conversation. This demonstrates that you value the relationship and the willingness to be vulnerable. “Thank you for having this conversation with me, I appreciate your openness.”

b. Identify next steps

If the issue has been resolved, great! If not, agree on a clear action plan. Set a follow-up date, outline the steps you’ll both take, and clarify any commitments made. For example, “I’d like us to revisit this in a week to check in on the changes we’ve agreed to make.”

By closing with clear next steps, you ensure that the conversation doesn’t lose momentum and that both of you are held accountable for moving forward.

c. Remain open to input

While you may have a specific outcome in mind, stay open to the other person’s input. Their perspective could offer insights that improve the situation in ways you hadn’t considered. Ultimately, the goal is mutual understanding and collaboration.

Difficult conversations are an inevitable part of leadership, but they don’t have to be dreaded. By preparing thoughtfully, creating a space for open communication, and focusing on solutions, you can navigate these challenging discussions with confidence and grace. Remember, these conversations don’t just resolve problems – they can also deepen relationships, foster trust, and lead to better outcomes for everyone involved.